Wizards of the Coast & the DnD OGL 1.1 Controversy

An offtopic area for discussing everything that ISN'T MetaZoo.


Post Reply
User avatar
Alex
Clubhouse Administrator
Posts: 90
Joined: Jan 1, 2023
Pronouns: They / Them
Location: BC, Canada
Contact:

There's nothing quite like standing on the edge of a large hole in the ground, looking down and going, "oh wow, they're still digging". In the case of Hasbro/WotC, apparently this is their new parttime job.

If you don't know what I'm talking about, or haven't heard yet, a quick recap; Wizards of the Coast, the subsidy of the Hasbro toy company responsible for your childhood, came under a lot of fire for accusations of money-grabbing recently for one of its staple brands, Magic: The Gathering, and is now apparently trying to do the same with its other staple brand, Dungeons and Dragons.

How, you ask? It's simple; WotC is apparently redoing its "Open Game License", a decades-old agreement that allows game punishers to use some DnD rules in their own supplementary products. This license is widely considered to be one of the things that helped explode the Kickstarter market, and has helped grow DnD into a household name over the past ten years. Every cool unofficial DnD product you have seen in your FLGS, every indie-published adventure, every DnD podcast/stream... All of it is made possible by the original OGL.

And now, WotG wants to revoke it (a thing they may not be able to do), and put in place a new agreement, which, according to new leaks, includes such hits as "give us 25% royalties if you have a successor Kickstarter" and "we can reprint your work without paying you whenever we want :)". Yeah, I am not joking about that last one; they want to introduce a worldwide royalty-free right for themselves in this new version, which means anyone who publishes under the new OGL 1.1 license will be agreeing to let WotC reprint or reuse their work at any point, without paying them any royalties. There are other things in there, such as owing WotC a certain percentage of sales after you make $750,000 (and no, it doesn't come out of your profits), having to destroy all your product if you get your license revoked for some reason, and having to register with them.

At the moment, OGL 1.1 hasn't been released, through they have announced they will - all of this is coming from leaks that happened over the last week. The obvious answer as to why seems to be 'money grab', but I won't lie - as a DnD player myself, I don't think I want to be throwing money at them right now. Given how much AI is stealing from artists right now, such a huge company (ya'll are coming out with a MOVIE for crying out loud) wanting to screw over small time content creators is just awful. What's your opinion on it?

Creator & Main Administrator behind the Caster Clubhouse Forum and MetaZoo Fandom Wiki.
Apprentice MetaZoologist who's been casting since Cryptid Nation, 1st edition!

User avatar
Alex
Clubhouse Administrator
Posts: 90
Joined: Jan 1, 2023
Pronouns: They / Them
Location: BC, Canada
Contact:

So the updates on this over the past few days have been wild. Here is a small amount of what I have seen;

  • Many companies announced they were going to build their own tabletop systems, including Kobold Press, which is one of the biggest third-party companies, and Pathfinder's parent company, Paizo, has announced they will also be making changes and divorcing themselves further from WotC.

  • On Tuesday, DnD FINALLY put out a tweet saying they knew people had questions, and they were 'thankful for everyone's patience'. Nobody was happy about this.

  • WotC cancelled both a livestream and than an announcement/release of the new license they were supposed to make on Thursday.

  • An email was leaked from inside DnD's company that did not cast the top office in a favourable light at all.

  • Because of this email, it became known that DnD was looking at subscription numbers for DnD Beyond as their chief metric, as it was easy and quick to measure. Mass calls went out for people to cancel their subscriptions, and boycott DnD in general.

And finally, the icing on the cake;

  • They FINALLY put out a statement on DnD Beyond today, which basically said they were going to be changing the upcoming license, and that they only had good intentions and never meant to hurt anyone's feelings. It has not been well received so far; https://www.dndbeyond.com/posts/1423-an ... icense-ogl

Personally - I am not happy about their attempts to hide behind "we were trying to prevent discrimination!!1!" excuse. Fuck that, that's just gross. That just reeks of 'but we were tRyInG to be the good guys!!!!' and victim blaming. Oh no, look at us, our players prevented us from doing good. :sealed: That loses them more points than if they'd said nothing at all, honestly, in my books. People's struggles to be accepted into the community should not be used as a weapon.

Creator & Main Administrator behind the Caster Clubhouse Forum and MetaZoo Fandom Wiki.
Apprentice MetaZoologist who's been casting since Cryptid Nation, 1st edition!

User avatar
Alex
Clubhouse Administrator
Posts: 90
Joined: Jan 1, 2023
Pronouns: They / Them
Location: BC, Canada
Contact:

It was a quiet weekend, news wise, until today/night - there has now been new leaks concerning the future of DnD Beyond. WotC apparently wants to introduce a subscription model to Beyond, which would be $30 at its highest tier, and would be tied into their virtual tabletop efforts in such a way that it would completely ban homebrew at lower tiers, and would introduce AI DMs??

Here's an interesting video, and some twitter threads;

Creator & Main Administrator behind the Caster Clubhouse Forum and MetaZoo Fandom Wiki.
Apprentice MetaZoologist who's been casting since Cryptid Nation, 1st edition!

User avatar
Alex
Clubhouse Administrator
Posts: 90
Joined: Jan 1, 2023
Pronouns: They / Them
Location: BC, Canada
Contact:

Another announcement from DnD Beyond; https://www.dndbeyond.com/posts/1428-a- ... me-license

Hasn't been terribly well received so far - mainly, it sounds like they may allow old content to continue under the original 1.0a, but no new content, which isn't actually that helpful. They're still insisting the contract sent out was a draft, even though... It was a contract they were trying to make people sign, which didn't say draft anywhere on it. Gaslighting. Gotta love it.

Creator & Main Administrator behind the Caster Clubhouse Forum and MetaZoo Fandom Wiki.
Apprentice MetaZoologist who's been casting since Cryptid Nation, 1st edition!

Post Reply